Defense Verdict in Motor Vehicle Accident Case

The case involved a motor vehicle accident at the corner of a busy City intersection. The plaintiffs were the driver and front-seat passenger of the first vehicle, and our client was driving the second vehicle. The plaintiffs alleged that defendant sideswiped their vehicle at a high rate of speed, resulting in a significant collision that lifted one side of their vehicle off the ground and jarred their bodies like they were on a rollercoaster. Both plaintiffs claimed TBIs and permanent neck and back injuries. After receiving emergency care, the plaintiffs embarked on an extended course of treatment at Advanced Injury Care and Advanced Training and Rehab.

At trial, the plaintiffs presented multiple damages witnesses and three medical experts specializing in orthopedic surgery, sports medicine, and pain management. Through cross-examination, the defense exposed significant weaknesses in the plaintiffs’ medical evidence. The experts lacked even a basic understanding of the accident mechanics, relied heavily on the plaintiffs’ subjective complaints despite contrary objective evidence, and failed to conduct meaningful forensic evaluations or adequately consider alternative explanations for the claimed symptoms. The defense also highlighted the frequency with which two of the experts testify for plaintiffs in personal injury cases.

The defendant’s case centered on the testimony of the defendant-driver and her passenger, photographs of the vehicles, and the plaintiffs’ inconsistent statements about how the accident occurred. Collectively, this evidence supported the defense position that there was either no contact between the vehicles or, at most, a minor sideswipe. The defense played the 911 call which featured both plaintiffs sounding uninjured, and a video posted by one of the plaintiffs on Facebook which showed her “twerking” despite her claims of a significant and permanent lower back injury.

The defense urged the jury to evaluate the claims against the objective evidence rather than accept the plaintiffs’ subjective complaints and the testimony of the doctors who unreasonably relied on them.

Following a three-day trial in the City of St. Louis Circuit Court, the jury returned a unanimous defense verdict.

Even in an era of increasingly sophisticated technology, a successful defense often begins with the fundamentals: a thorough factual investigation, compelling objective evidence, and focused cross-examination. Photographs, 911 audio, and relevant video footage remain powerful tools for the defense, allowing jurors to peek beyond the curtain of the courtroom stage and see the real facts of the case.